I got it to work with help from Elk Tech Support. Two things: 1) I setup a free email address that does not require SSL at lavabit.com. 2) I changed the TCP/IP settings from static IP, etc. to DHCP. Rebooted and everything worked fine. Not sure why the static IP didn't work and don't really care, as long as it works. Elk also reminded me that when sending Emails from Rules, ELK-RP must be disconnected.